Contract Forecast: Colin Kaepernick
Untitled Document

Contract Forecast: Colin Kaepernick

Colin Kaepernick has led the San Francisco 49ers to back-to-back NFC Championship games, and a Super Bowl appearance in 2012. His dyanmic play style mixed with a fiery personality (much like his head coach), has returned the 49ers to their elite status. Now through his third NFL season, Kaepernick is eligible for an extension to his $5.12M rookie scaled contract. As of now, he's set to earn $1.073M in cash, with a cap figure of $1.63M for the 2014 season.

Much like our forecast for Panthers QB Cam Newton, Kaepernick's unique skill set lends itself to varying evaluation methods. He may be the first of the current generation of "young mobile quarterbacks" to be granted a long-term contract.

To compensate for this, we'll revise the statistics used in our analysis to include Rushing Yards, and Total Touchdowns (Passing + Throwing). Additionally, we'll take a look at the Top 10 rushing quarterbacks since 2011 to find where Kaepernick falls solely based on his run game.

We'll assess Kaepernick's statistical performance in 2012-13 and compare them to quarterbacks of similar age and production to determine and forecast a possible extension this offseason.

Comparable Quarterbacks
To generate a prediction the Spotrac team determined that the following quarterbacks were viable targets to use in comparing with Kaepernick. The key was to locate players with similar numbers, who signed their second contract around Colin's current age (26). Here's a look at the new money for each extension signed by each. To determine a more likely starting point for our numbers, we'll perform a linear regression of each contract breakdown listed below.
Player Length Value Avg. Salary Guaranteed Age When Signed
Joe Flacco 6 $120,600,000 $20,100,000 $29,000,000.00 27
Aaron Rodgers 4 $110,000,000.00 $20,000,000 $20,000,000.00 30
Matt Ryan 6 $103,750,000 $17,291,666 $42,000,000.00 27
Matthew Stafford 3 $53,000,000 $17,666,666 $33,500,000.00 25
Averages 5 $96,837,500 $19,264,583 $31,125,000 26
At 26 years old, Kaepernick is younger than the majority of our variable quarterbacks (Matthew Stafford signed at age 25). We'll adjust the above contracts up/down to reflect each as if it were signed at the age of 26 to provide a better scope for our base prediction.

Related:  View the list of Top Average Paid Quarterbacks in the NFL
Length Value Avg. Salary (slope)
6 $120,798,737 $20,133,122

Statistical Analysis

Due to the need to include the rushing aspect of his game, our choice of statistics used to evaluate Kaepernick will differ from many of our other QB forecasts. To derive the most complete set of production comparisons, we'll use Games/Season, Passing Yards/Season, Completion %/Season, Total TDs (Passing & Rushing)/Season, , Interceptions/Season, and Rushing Yards/Season.

To assess how well the player was performing prior to signing their respective contract, we'll show the averages of these statistics two years prior to their signing date. Becase Kaepernick entered the 49ers lineup a few games into the 2012 season, we've done the math to project his statistics as if he were the starting QB for all 16 2012 games. The two-year analysis will give us a "Prime Percentage", showing how well that player was performing when the contract was signed in relation to his overall career.

Player Games/YR Pass YDS/YR Comp %/YR Total TD/YR INT/G Rush YDS/YR (50%)
Matt Ryan (2011-12, ATL) 16 4448 64.95 32 13 112.5
Joe Flacco (2011-12, BAL) 16 3713.5 58.65 23 11 55
Matthew Stafford (2011-12, DET) 16 5002.5 61.65 32.5 16.5 102
Aaron Rodgers (2008-09, GB) 16 4236 64.15 33.5 10 261.5
AVERAGES 16 4350 62.35 30.25 12.625 132.75
Colin Kaepernick (2012,13, SF) 16 2714 59.8 21 5.5 517
% Change 0.00% -37.61% -4.09% -30.58% 56.44% 144.73%
MEDIAN PRIME PERCENTAGE: -2.04%
Contrary to what the 2013 NFC Chamionship game may have showed, Kaepernick has been great at keeping the ball out of the other team's hands regularly. Where he lacks in passing yards (-38%), he makes up for with his legs. A drop in completion percentage in 2013 might be of note, as it dipped under the 60% mark. We'll factor his slight -2.04% Prime Percentage into our base numbers.

Quarterback Rushing Stats Since 2011
The following shows a cumulative breakdown of rushing statistics by quarterbacks from 2011 through 2013. Kaepernick finds himself with the second most rushing TDs, and 6th most rushing yards per game among the mobile quarterbacks.
Player Games Attempts Yards Rush TDS YDS/GAME
Robert Griffin (WAS) 28 206 1,304 7 46.60
Cam Newton (CAR) 48 364 2,032 28 42.33
Terrelle Pryor (OAK) 15 93 627 3 41.80
Michael Vick (PHI) 30 174 1,227 4 40.90
Russell Wilson (SEA) 32 190 1,028 5 32.10
Colin Kaepernick (SF) 32 157 937 9 29.30
Tim Tebow (DEN / NYJ) 30 58 762 6 25.40
Andrew Luck (IND) 32 125 632 9 19.75
Alex Smith (SF / KC) 41 159 742 3 18.10
Christian Ponder (MIN) 35 122 623 6 17.30

Results

Length of the Contract
At 26 years old, and further instantiating himself as the long-term franchise quarterback solution in San Franciso, it's perfectly likely the the 49ers extend Kaepernick out 7-8 years (keeping in mind that many of these lengthy deals have outs WELL before their expiration). For purposes of evaluation, we'll keep the length of this forecast at 6 years, the mathematical average.

Value of the Contract
Our initial base contract provided an average salary of just over $20.13 million per year, a figure that would place him 3rd among active quarterbacks. Our statistical comparison brought that number down to early slightly, with a 2.04% decrease.

Quick Thoughts
As a former 2nd-round pick, the 49ers don't have the ability to exercise a 5th year option on Kaepernick (something the Panthers can do with Cam Newton). With nearly $119.4M cap dollars allocated to their 2014 salary cap already, and a fairly potent list of 2014 free agents the 49ers have some work to do to make ends meet this offseason. As it stands, Kaepernick's $1.63M cap figure ranks 38th among 2014 quarterbacks, certainly a value. Financial strain or not, it makes sense on both sides for this extension to get done in the coming months, even if it means restructuring other veteran contracts (Vernon Davis, Frank Gore) to find the space.

Spotrac's Prediction: 6 years, $118,382,000
Average annual salary $19,730, 000, estimated $43,847,000 guaranteed

Follow Spotrac on Twitter, and keep up with even more on Facebook.

Recent Premium Reports

  • NFL Free Agent Spending Breakdowns
    We're 1 month, $2 billion, and 274 contracts into the 2014 NFL Free Agency Season, a reasonable time to begin breaking down the figures by Team Spending, Positional Spending, and guaranteed dollars. This and more: » View this Report
  • Contract Forecast: DeSean Jackson
    His release from the Eagles last week opened many eyes across the league. Now DeSean Jackson is the most coveted free agent weapon left on the market. We'll assess a value prediction for what his next contract might look like. » View this Report
  • Contract Forecast: Andy Dalton
    One of the bigger question marks heading into the 2014 NFL League year is the long-term fate of Cincinnati Bengals quarterback Andy Dalton, whose rookie contract is set to expire after the season. We'll assess Dalton's value for a contract extension this offseason. » View this Report
  • 2014 NFL Positional Cap Spending
    An in-depth look at how each NFL team is spending their 2014 cap dollars positionally, including total dollars, percent of cap space, the average player cap hit, and much more. » View this Report

» Visit the Research Center

» Visit the Research Center

» Visit the Research Center

» Visit the Research Center

» Visit the Research Center